How to Swirl Soap Using Natural Colorants

348 Shares
This article contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Tips for swirling soap with natural colors including the best soap recipes to use, videos of swirling techniques, and recommended natural colorants #soapmaking #soaprecipe #diybeauty

Lovely Greens Botanical Soapmaking Ebook



There are many kinds of multicolored soap. Some use embeds or shredded soap pieces to create confetti soap, while others can be poured in bands or layers. Swirling soap involves pouring different colored portions of soap batter together, often using a tool like a chopstick or hanger to create intricate patterns or swirls. There are many techniques, and you can have a lot of fun with the different designs.

As a natural soap maker, I create soap with beautiful botanical color. Sunny yellow carrot soap, soft-purple alkanet soap, and steel-blue woad soap. These recipes are relatively easy to make, even if some ingredients and steps differ from conventional soap recipes. What they all have in common, though, is that single-color soap is usually easier to make when you’re working with natural soap colorants.

Where there’s a will, there’s a way, though, and I’d like to share some tips for swirling soap with natural colors. Use them, along with these suggested swirling techniques, to create beautiful multi-colored swirls in your bars using purely natural ingredients.

Coloring Multiple Portions of Soap

When swirling soap, you typically start by making a single large batch and bringing it to emulsion or the lightest trace possible. Then divide the soap batter into separate containers and color each one individually, typically with a small amount of concentrated color. How you pour them into a mold and what you do with the soap after creates the swirls.

Portions of soap being colored before being swirled together.

However, many natural soap colorants aren’t as easy to add. They’re usually something much more fundamental to the recipe, such as an infused oil or puree. Even when they are a powder, you either infuse the water or oil (like turmeric or indigo), or they have more subtle color you have to be careful how much you use (like clays).

Soap swirled with paprika-infused oil and charcoal. See recipe

Some of the most incredible natural soap colors come from making soap using infused oils. With this technique, you can use infused oil at up to 100% of the oils in a soap recipe. For example, you could infuse olive oil with calendula flowers, then use the colored oil to make yellow soap.

If you split a batch of infused-oil soap and color a portion of it with another soap colorant, the result is often a mix of the original color and the new one. Imagine mixing paint colors, and you’ll get the picture. To keep the colors cleaner, you may want to make two separate batches of soap, which you can color independently. You can see this technique in the paprika and charcoal soap recipe.

Natural vs. Artificial Soap Colorants

If you’ve ever seen cold-process soap swirled in vibrant turquoise, bright red, or neon yellow, the colors are most likely artificial. The shades they create are stunning and are considered safe for personal care. They include FD&C colors (synthetic dyes) and micas. You can’t use them in natural soap since they are artificial ingredients.

Holiday-themed soap made with the in-the-pot swirl technique

You can also make brightly colored, swirled soap using mineral pigments such as oxides and ultramarines. These are nature-identical ingredients rather than fully natural ones. They’re the colorants, along with micas, that are used to make mineral makeup. You use them like micas—split an uncolored batch of soap into different jugs and color each one differently.

Tips for swirling soap with natural colors including the best soap recipes to use, videos of swirling techniques, and recommended natural colorants #soapmaking #soaprecipe #diybeauty
Soap swirled with woad and turmeric.

In some cases, you can add a natural soap colorant to soap batter the same way you would a synthetic colorant. With clay or charcoal, first mix with a little water, oil, or vegetable glycerine, then stir it in.

Natural Soap Colorants to Add to Soap Batter

The easiest way to swirl natural soap is to make a single batch of uncolored soap, split it, then color the different portions. Some natural soap colorants can be used this way, but they usually won’t be as bright or bold as synthetic colors. They can be lovely in their own right, and these are the best ingredients to use that way:

  • Activated charcoal, powder (gray and black)
  • Clays, powders in various colors (pink, blue, gray, brick-red, brown, green, purple)
  • Cocoa powder (brown)
  • Coffee granules, mixed into a little water (light to brown)
  • Dried herbs, to leave swirls of herb speckles (brown to black)
  • Dried tea leaves, to create swirls of speckles (brown to black)
  • Indigo extract, powder (light to dark blue)
  • Madder root, powder (pink, mauve, magenta)
  • Paprika, powder (pink to orange)
  • Poppyseeds

How Much Colorant to Use When Swirling Soap

Silicone loaf molds are the most popular soap molds for creating swirled soap, and the smallest size I’ve seen is for a 1-lb (454 g) batch. I use many silicone molds, and the 28 oz (800 g) size is my favorite. The weight measurement refers to the amount of oil/butters in a soap recipe, not the total weight of the recipe. You can also use much larger soap molds, and homemade ones made of wood or cardboard lined with greaseproof paper work, too.

For 800 g (28 oz) batches of soap, I use up to five teaspoons of powdered colorant. I first mix the powder in a small amount of water and add it bit by bit until I like the color. You can use a little more or less, though, depending on the shade you’re trying to achieve.

Keep in mind that too much color can cause a few issues, though. That includes coming off the bar, tinting the lather, and leaving streaks on your sink or tub. Some natural colorants, such as madder powder, may also feel slightly gritty if you use too much. Also, keep in mind that gelling soap (more info further below) can help intensify colors. You’ll never really know the final color until you cut and cure a batch.

Use Slow-Moving Soap to Create Swirls

In simple soap recipes, a quick trace time usually isn’t a big issue. When your soap begins thickening, stir in your essential oil, pour it into molds, and you’re finished. To make swirls, slow trace down so you have time to work. You should also aim to mix your soap batter to emulsion rather than trace.

To avoid soap batter that thickens too quickly, minimize immersion blending, avoid soap recipes that are too heavily water-discounted, and avoid fragrances that accelerate trace. It’s also best to mix the lye solution and oils between 85-95°F (29-35°C) and skip recipes high in fats that trace quickly. Saturated fats like cocoa butter, palm oil, shea butter, and coconut oil speed up trace time. If it’s solid at room temperature, it’s likely to speed up trace. Recipes high in castor oil can also speed up trace time.

Best Soap Recipe for Swirling

You can swirl many soap recipes, but one that doesn’t reach full trace quickly is best. The slowest-moving soap recipe is probably pure olive oil soap, also called castile soap. If you make it with extra virgin olive oil (EVOO), it’ll be at its slowest, and you’ll have plenty of time to work. However, the soap’s natural color can sometimes be light yellow to greenish-yellow. At least initially. That color can interfere with any additional colors you might want to add.

Soap recipes high in unsaturated oils and fats, like olive oil, tend to trace slower.

Pomace olive oil will be lighter in color, but it does trace a bit quicker than EVOO. Still, castile soap made with pomace olive oil could be a great candidate for the best soap recipe for swirling. You can also use other recipes high in canola oil or high-oleic sunflower oil—basically, soaps with high percentages (above 50%) of unsaturated fatty acids.

Wavy Chopstick Swirl

Tahitian Swirl Technique

Hanger Swirl

Divider Chopstick Swirl

Gel Phase for Swirled Soap

Once you have poured and swirled your soap, make sure it gels. Natural soap colorants can often be earthy and subdued if left ungelled, and the distinction between layers might not be as sharp. Gel phase and its effects happen after you pour the soap into a mold. It continues heating up, with the center being the warmest. If you peek at your soap, you can often see it happening—the center often having a darker circular spot. If the soap is kept warm, gel phase will eventually spread from the middle out to all edges.

The oven is warm but turned off when you place the soap inside.

If you encourage gel phase, the finished soap will have a slightly translucent appearance on the surface. The colors can brighten and deepen, too! Gel phase is purely aesthetic, though, and has no other properties. If your soap forms a partial gel, it will behave and perform as normal. Partial gel happens most often in soap poured into loaf molds—the centers of each bar, when cut, will have a darker circular area in the middle.

To encourage gel phase to happen, you insulate your soap or keep it warm. Some soapmakers set their soap on a heating pad, and others wrap the mold in a fluffy towel overnight. I prefer oven processing soap.

To oven-process soap, preheat your oven to 170°F (75°C) while you’re making a batch. Once you pour your soap batter into the mold(s), turn off the oven, place the mold(s) inside, and shut the door. Leave the soap inside overnight; the oven’s warmth and insulation will ensure the gel phase happens.

Naturally Coloring Handmade Soap

The tips above will help you make swirled soap using natural colorants of your choice. Experiment to your heart’s content, and have fun! When you start something new, you’re bound to have successes and challenges, so don’t worry about perfecting swirling on your first attempts. If you’d like to explore more ideas for making plant-based soap, check out these creative ideas:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

12 Comments

  1. Hello, will this work for 100% tallow soap recipe? thank you very much

    1. Hi Julia, tallow soap tends to move much more slowly than other ‘hard oils’ in soap recipes. Meaning, it should give you plenty of time to do your swirling!

      1. Thank you! I haven’t tried colorants yet but cant wait, I am brand new to soap making :) There is so much to learn, its a little overwhelming. I noticed there aren’t many colored beef tallow soaps, most sold are just the natural off-white/white. Is there a reason? Do you recommend I incorporate another oil that will help me achieve colors and patterns in soap? Thanks again, your website is so helpful.

        1. I’m guessing here, but it seems to me that many tallow soapmakers seem to be homesteader types. It may be a matter of practicality than anything else! I know one person in Australia who does color her tallow soap but it’s with simple single colors like activated charcoal and spirulina.

  2. Tanya,

    This is the best article regarding the use of natural colorants and swirling that I’ve seen – and I have no less than 90 bookmarked articles and videos! (Obviously I’ve read or watched at least 3 to 5 times that many!)

    I love that you cover all the what’s and how’s that have plagued my attempts with natural colorants and swirls.

    Thank you! (I’m off to try a yellow, orange and black swirl.)

    Respectfully,
    Lynette

    1. I’m so happy to help, Lynette! Thank you for your kind words and good luck with your swirling experiments :)

  3. Charles chike says:

    In soap making if my soap happens to trace so quick than required, thereby hardening so fast do I need to add a little water to slow it down and bringing it to liquid or pasteurization before pouring into the mould

    1. There are a few reasons that soap batter sets quickly – using smaller amounts of water, oils and fats that trace quickly, and using certain soap additives, such as certain essential oils and fragrance oils. You’ll need to work out what reason(s) your soap recipe is setting so quickly and adjust the recipe from there.

  4. I’m a beginner. Why not make 2 recipes and swirl them together? Like a turmeric soap and a French clay soap? Or am I oversimplifying things?

    1. You can, but it’s easier said than done! Melting two batches of soap, cooling the lye solution to the same temperature, and bringing both to trace at the same time can get complicated.

  5. Trish Stewart says:

    First, I love your site and I’m looking forward to incorporating natural colours in my soaps. I know that you are supposed to add tumeric to the lye water, but I would like to add it to divided batter at thin trace in different amounts and pour a 3 layer loaf. My idea would be to first mix each tumeric with a small amount of oil then add to each divided batter. Would I have to strain each oil before adding to trace? I would like to divide each layer with a thin dusting of charcoal powder. Will this work? I would appreciate your advice.

    1. Hi Trish, you can of course seperate out your soap batter and add turmeric to some/each. It helps to mix the turmeric with a little water before adding it though — just enough to make a wet paste. Otherwise, it has a tendency to leave clumps and speckles. Another piece of advice: use a light hand with turmeric. Adding too much can cause the soap to create yellowish lather and potentially tint your tub or shower.