Make this Traditional Rum Shrub Recipe like a Victorian Smuggler

How to make traditional rum shrub using citrus fruits, ginger, and dark rum. Shrub is a victorian rum liqueur that is delicious sipped neat or used to make sweet cocktails.

A few weeks ago a friend gave me a small jar of an amber coloured liquid she called ‘Shrub’. To me it looked a bit deadly and to be honest I was afraid to smell it let alone taste it. Imagine my surprise when just a few days later I screwed the top to discover the sweet aroma of rum sweetened with sugar, citrus, and spices. The unusual liqueur had the consistency of light sugary syrup and tasted like something Victorian ladies might have sipped after dinner. I was hooked.

As it turns out, Shrub is an entire category of rum-based liqueur with quite an illustrious history. In the days of bootlegging and smuggling, barrels of rum used to be sunk in harbours off the south coast of England only to be pulled back up when the coast was clear.

Unfortunately, the liquor’s sojourn in the sea left it with a brackish flavour due to small amounts of saltwater seeping in through the barrels’ seams. Instead of throwing the whole lot out, some forgotten genius figured out how the saltiness could be disguised with sugar and spices to make it palatable, and more importantly saleable.

My Take on a Traditional Rum Shrub Recipe

Since then Shrub has become famous as the drink made by Phillips of Bristol and is a traditional tipple in places like Cornwall, where it’s served with even more rum. It has also been rediscovered by trendy bars where its intense sweet flavour is being used to compliment mixed drinks and cocktails.

Though Phillips’ Shrub is relatively inexpensive, I’ve not been able to find it for sale anywhere on the Isle of Man. There’s always the option to buy it online and have it shipped over but I thought it might be more fun to try making it myself.

Though I can’t be absolutely certain of which herbs and spices are used in the genuine product, I had a look at traditional Shrub recipes, took an educated guess and came up with a drink that is both similar and delicious. Sweet but not sickly sweet, the fruity flavour of oranges and lemons and rich Autumnal spices comes through beautifully. My version is also a little bit boozier than the original so it’s possible to have it neat without being overwhelmed by sweetness.

Traditional Rum Shrub Recipe

Makes approx. 1.5 L

Day One
1 Pint Jamaican Dark Rum
3/4 cup freshly squeezed orange juice
1/8 cup freshly squeezed lemon juice
Zest of one lemon
Zest of one orange
1.5″ piece of ginger, sliced
1 Cinnamon stick
1/8 tsp grated Nutmeg
8 Cloves

After the infusion period
2 Tbsp Honey
1 Bottle (750ml) White wine
400g White granulated sugar

Step 1. Take all the ingredients listed in ‘Day One’ and place them into a glass jar. Store the jar in a dark place for a full week taking it out once a day to give it a gentle shake.

Juice note: The juice quantities are what I got from squeezing the one large orange and lemon after I zested them. As fruits differ in size and juice quantities please make sure to measure your own juice for consistency’s sake.
Zest note: If you’re not sure what zest is I’ve posted a photo above to show it as the finely grated skin of citrus fruits that excludes the bitter white pith. I have a zesting tool that I use all the time (pictured above next to the lemon) but it’s also possible to use a cheese grater to get the job done.
Spices note: It’s important to use whole spices rather than their powdered versions because you want your liqueur to end up as clear as possible. It’s more difficult to filter out powdered spices than whole ones but if you only have powders and don’t mind some haziness then go ahead and use them.

Step 2. Strain the liquid through muslin or a jelly bag at least twice if not three times. Your aim is to remove as many of the ‘bits’ as possible. Leave your final filtered liquid in a jar to settle for at least a few hours and preferably overnight. If you have a jar that has a spout, like the tea infuser I use, it will make the final step easier.

Step 3. Place the entire bottle of white wine into a saucepan and heat on low until the wine is just warm. Do not bring it to a simmer or you’ll lose alcohol to heat and evaporation. When warm, take the wine off the hob and then stir in the honey and the sugar until it’s completely dissolved. Allow the wine to cool to room temperature.

Wine Note: I’ve used an inexpensive Chardonnay in this recipe but probably any light flavoured white wine will do.

Step 4. Gently pour the infused rum into the sugared wine leaving as much of the sediment in the container as possible. Though not harmful, this residue of fruit and spices will be unsightly and can cloud your liqueur.

Step 5. Pour your Shrub into clean, sterilised bottles, store them in a dark place, and allow them to mature for a week before serving. This week helps to clear the alcohol but also adds mellows out the flavour but if you can’t wait that long go ahead and have a sneaky sample. Due to the fresh juice used in this recipe, try to use your final alcohol within four to six weeks. Refrigeration will also help to prolong the shelf-life.

Homemade Liqueur Recipes

Rum shrub isn’t the only alcoholic treat that you can whip up at home. Here’s even more homemade liqueur recipes that you can make easily and inexpensively:

• Homemade Kahlua Recipe (coffee liqueur)
• Blackberry Gin Recipe
• Homemade Baileys (takes five minutes)
• Rhubarb Gin Recipe